Skull and Bones at Yale: The Secret Society, the Tomb and the 1876 Break-In
On the evening of 29 September 1876, a group of Yale students completed an elaborate burglary. Their target was not a bank, a wealthy professor's house or the college wine cellar.
It was a windowless sandstone building on High Street, protected by iron doors, barred windows and an atmosphere of almost theatrical secrecy.
Inside was the headquarters of Skull and Bones, the mysterious senior society whose members would eventually include American presidents, intelligence officials and some of the country's most influential public figures.
The intruders hoped to expose the secrets of an organisation already surrounded by rumours of strange rituals and extraordinary power.
What they discovered was considerably more peculiar.
A Secret Society with an Unusually Public Beginning
The Skull and Bones Yale secret society was established in 1832 by students including William Huntington Russell and Alphonso Taft, father of future president William Howard Taft.
Originally known among its members as the Eulogian Club, the society adopted its macabre identity after an early member drew a skull and crossbones on a meeting notice displayed at Yale's chapel.
The drawing was apparently intended to attract attention.
It succeeded rather spectacularly.
Skull and Bones developed into an exclusive senior society, selecting a small group of students each year and surrounding its meetings with elaborate customs and carefully maintained secrecy.
Members became known as Bonesmen. Initiates were called knights, graduates patriarchs, and outsiders barbarians.
For an organisation supposedly dedicated to keeping itself hidden, it developed a remarkably conspicuous vocabulary.
Its emblem combined a skull and crossed bones with the number 322, whose precise significance remains disputed. One historical interpretation connects it with 322 BCE and the death of the Greek orator Demosthenes.
Other explanations have circulated for generations, providing conspiracy enthusiasts with a seemingly inexhaustible supply of numerical possibilities.
The Tomb: A Building Designed to Keep Secrets
In 1856, the society moved into a purpose-built headquarters on High Street in New Haven.
Known simply as the Tomb, the building was an imposing rectangular structure of sandstone, designed in an Egypto-Doric style and almost entirely without windows.
Its heavy iron doors stood approximately twelve feet high. The roof and other vulnerable areas were reinforced, while barred openings protected the basement.
The architectural message was unmistakable.
Whatever happened inside was none of your business.
The building was later expanded, but the original structure already possessed everything necessary to inspire generations of speculation: imposing masonry, strange symbols, restricted access and a clientele drawn from Yale's privileged student population.
The Night the Outsiders Got In
In September 1876, a group of students calling themselves the Order of the File and Claw decided to investigate.
They spent hours cutting through protective ironwork at the rear of the building, carefully concealing their preparations before returning on the evening of 29 September.
By approximately 10.30pm, they were inside.
Their subsequent account, published in a pamphlet titled Babylon Is Fallen, provides one of the most entertaining glimpses into nineteenth-century collegiate secrecy.
The basement contained a kitchen, pantry, toilet and a human skull. Upstairs, the intruders discovered decorated rooms, a library, ceremonial objects and collections of society memorabilia.
One display case contained gilded baseballs commemorating university games.
Not quite the instruments of global domination they may have anticipated.
The most important room, numbered 322, contained a large representation of the society's emblem set into a marble fireplace. Nearby was a Latin motto: Rari Quippe Boni — roughly, "The good are indeed few."
The intruders also examined the society's safe.
Its contents included keys and a small flask containing brandy.
After considerable effort, the supposed inner workings of America's most mysterious student society appeared to consist largely of books, photographs, sporting trophies and the occasional drink.
The investigators concluded that they had uncovered something resembling an exclusive social club.
Which, considering the amount of trouble involved in getting through the basement window, must have been mildly disappointing.
Presidents, Bonesmen and the Politics of Secrecy
Skull and Bones nevertheless became an influential institution.
Its alumni included William Howard Taft, George H. W. Bush, George W. Bush and John Kerry, alongside prominent figures from business, law and intelligence.
The 2004 American presidential election offered an extraordinary coincidence: both major candidates, George W. Bush and Kerry, had belonged to the same secretive Yale society.
Such connections helped transform an undergraduate organisation into a permanent fixture of American conspiracy culture.
But there is an important distinction between an exclusive network whose members later acquire power and an organisation secretly directing world affairs.
The first is documented. The second requires evidence that its more extravagant theorists have not established.
Other controversies are more substantial. A 1918 letter discovered in Yale's archives referred to society members allegedly removing the remains of Apache leader Geronimo from his grave. The claim has been disputed, and the letter does not establish that the remains were actually Geronimo's.
Here the mythology touches genuine historical questions about privilege, appropriation and accountability.
The Real Secret Behind Skull and Bones
Nearly two centuries after its foundation, Skull and Bones remains a remarkably effective generator of mystery.
Its symbols are ominous, its building forbidding and its membership list unusually distinguished.
Yet the most revealing episode in its history may still be the night a group of curious students forced their way inside and discovered that the machinery of secrecy was considerably less impressive than its reputation.
The Tomb protected something real: an exclusive network of influential people, its traditions and its collective identity.
It did not need supernatural powers or an invisible world government to become fascinating.
Sometimes the most effective secret is simply persuading everybody outside that there must be something extraordinary behind the door.
Discover Hellwood's Skull and Bones T-Shirt, featuring the society's distinctive skull-and-crossbones emblem and the mysterious number 322.
For more organisations operating beyond ordinary public scrutiny, explore the Cults & Secret Societies collection or browse Hellwood's Conspiracy Theory T-Shirts.
SKULL AND BONES T-SHIRT
America's most mysterious university society.
A Hellwood tribute to the legendary Skull and Bones society of Yale University, founded in 1832 and surrounded by nearly two centuries of secrecy, influence and speculation.
Featuring the society's unmistakable skull-and-crossbones emblem, the mysterious number 322 and distressed historical lettering.
VIEW THE SKULL AND BONES T-SHIRT